Exploring the Viability of Converting Your Inherited Property into a Rental

Eddie Van Buskirk • May 15, 2024

Inheriting a property is a significant event that brings both opportunities and challenges. Among the array of decisions to be made, one option worth considering is converting the inherited property into a rental. While this strategy presents potential financial benefits and long-term gains, it's imperative to conduct a thorough analysis of the pros and cons. In this discourse, we'll delve into the rationale behind converting your inherited property into a rental, alongside an examination of the associated risks. 

Pros of Turning Your Inherited Property into a Rental: 

Establishment of Passive Income Streams:

Transforming your inherited property into a rental venture offers the prospect of generating passive income. The rental proceeds from tenants can serve to offset mortgage payments, property taxes, and maintenance expenses, thereby fostering a foundation of financial stability over time.


Safeguarding Family Assets:

Opting to retain ownership and lease the inherited property can serve as a means of safeguarding family wealth for future generations. Rather than opting for immediate liquidation, renting out the property facilitates the preservation of its intrinsic value, potentially allowing for capital appreciation in the long run.


Leveraging Tax Incentives:

Ownership of a rental property unlocks various tax advantages, including deductions for mortgage interest, property taxes, and depreciation. These tax incentives serve to mitigate the overall tax liability, thereby augmenting the allure of converting the inherited property into a rental endeavor.


Utilizing the equity

In a lot of cases, an inherited property will be 100% paid off or the mortgage is very small and the payment is extremely low. Since this is the case the cash flow that the property will produce is great and any expenses that might arise can be covered out of the monthly rent. This also makes it so you are going to take advantage of depreciation and see great appreciation in value. 

Risks Associated with Turning Your Inherited Property into a Rental: 

Navigating Property Management Complexities:

Managing a rental property requires a comprehensive understanding of tenant relations, maintenance protocols, and legal obligations. Inadequate management practices can precipitate tenant disputes, property damage, and financial setbacks, underscoring the importance of proficient property oversight. You might think I will manage the property myself which is an option but you need to ask yourself what is your time worth and do I want to deal with tenant issues on my days off or when I am with my family? If you want to truly have passive income then having a property manager is the way to go. Make sure you talk to a lot of property management companies and you are comfortable with the one you are hiring.


Exposure to Market Volatility:

The rental market is susceptible to fluctuations influenced by supply-demand dynamics, economic shifts, and regulatory changes. Volatility in rental income and property valuations poses inherent risks, requiring prudent risk assessment to safeguard against adverse market conditions. Rents in the Kansas City market have been stable and rising for the last 5 years so it is unlikely that you would see a huge dip but it is a factor to consider. Signing tenants for longer-term leases like 18-24 month terms secures your property for cash flow unless the tenant stops paying which is always a chance when having rentals. 


Mitigating Unforeseen Expenditures:

Owning a rental property entails ongoing expenses, encompassing maintenance, insurance, property management fees, and vacancy costs. Unforeseen expenditures can erode rental income and diminish overall investment returns, necessitating vigilant financial planning and risk mitigation strategies. Taking the proper steps when getting your property ready to be rented can help reduce the likelihood of unexpected expenses. Since you probably have not lived in the house we recommend having an inspection done of the property to highlight any problems you may not see. This is the best way to not be burdened with extremely high Maintenance costs



It can make a lot of sense to make an inherited property into a rental property when evaluating the prospect of converting your inherited property into a rental, a judicious appraisal of the associated advantages and risks is indispensable. While the allure of passive income, asset preservation, and tax incentives is compelling, the complexities of property management, market volatility, and financial contingencies merit careful consideration. By conducting a thorough analysis and seeking professional guidance, you can make an informed decision aligned with your overarching financial objectives and risk tolerance. Kansas City Legacy Properties can help you make your inherited property into a rental and manage it for you so give us a call today at 816-307-7163 to learn more. 


By Eddie Van Buskirk June 30, 2025
No one ever expects to be in this situation. Losing someone to suicide is devastating. It's painful, confusing, and can leave you feeling paralyzed. If you’re also the person tasked with handling their estate or have inherited their property, that emotional burden gets even heavier. At KC Legacy Properties, we've walked beside families going through this very experience. It's heartbreaking. And it's our mission to make sure no one has to go through it alone. The Overwhelming Reality of Inheriting a Property in Tragic Circumstances When someone passes unexpectedly—especially by suicide—there's often no plan in place. Suddenly, you're facing rent due, contents to sort, legal questions, and deep emotional wounds. We've seen families struggle with where to start: How do you clear out a loved one's belongings without reliving the trauma? What if you're far away, or emotionally unable to face the property? How do you protect the estate from further financial damage? These are questions no one prepares for. But we can help you answer them. Real Stories, Real Solutions In one case, a family member called us because they were emotionally detached enough to manage the process, but still deeply concerned about shielding others from trauma. Together, we made a list of items to keep, walked through the apartment via Zoom, and carefully retrieved the important belongings. The rest was donated or discarded, allowing them to stop paying rent on the unit and move forward. In another situation, a man inherited his brother’s home but was frozen by grief. For a year, nothing happened. Squatters had broken in. The house risked being lost to back taxes. We visited him personally, gently walked him through each step—collecting items, clearing the property, resolving title issues, and eventually helping him sell the home. Without that partnership, he might still be stuck in limbo. You Don't Have to Face This Alone The truth is, dealing with an inherited home after suicide is too much to take on all at once. That’s why our approach is simple: one step at a time. First, identify and protect valuables and documents. Then, make decisions about belongings—donation, storage, sale or disposal. Next, resolve title or legal issues. Finally, decide whether to sell traditionally or explore a cash option. We never pressure you. We simply help you move forward, at your pace, with dignity and transparency. KC Legacy Properties: Here When You Need Us Most We know you're grieving. And we want you to know: you're not alone. Whether you need someone to hold your hand through the process or just want honest advice, we're here to help. And if you decide you want a cash offer to simply walk away, we can make that happen too. But we’ll always show you all your options so you can make the best decision for your future.  Reach out today. Call us at (816) 307-7163 or fill out the inquiry form at KC Legacy Properties . We're here to listen, and to help.
By Eddie Van Buskirk June 25, 2025
You found a buyer, you signed the contract, and now you’re just waiting to close—right? Not so fast. Some of the most common (and expensive) real estate mistakes happen after the offer is accepted. The good news? If you're the seller, you can avoid almost all of them with the right game plan. At KC Legacy Properties, we help our sellers close with confidence—not chaos. Here are 10 avoidable reasons your home sale might fall apart, and how to steer clear of every one: 1. Delaying Agreed-Upon Repairs If you promised to fix something, get it done—on time. Buyers can legally walk if you don’t deliver. 2. Blocking Appraisals or Inspections Don’t cancel or restrict access. It slows the process and raises red flags for buyers. 3. Trying to Renegotiate After Signing The contract is the contract. Changing dates, keeping appliances, or adding new demands puts the deal at risk. 4. Hiding Known Issues Undisclosed problems (like mold or foundation cracks) almost always surface—and buyers don’t like surprises. 5. Not Being Ready to Move If you can’t hand over keys on time, you’re breaking the agreement. Have a real exit plan, not a guess. 6. Title Problems Unpaid taxes, old liens, or ownership disputes? They’ll come up. Address them early to avoid delays or cancellations. 7. Leaving the Home in Bad Condition Buyers do a final walkthrough for a reason. If the home is dirty, damaged, or missing agreed-upon items, they can walk away at the finish line. 8. Getting Cold Feet Once you're under contract, backing out isn’t just emotional—it can lead to legal trouble. Be sure before you list. 9. Ignoring Paperwork or Deadlines Missing documents or delayed responses can tank your timeline. Stay responsive and on top of everything. 10. Overreacting to Buyer Requests Not every inspection request is personal. Stay calm and negotiate smart—small concessions can save the whole deal. Thinking About Selling? Just getting to contract isn’t enough—you need to get to closing. At KC Legacy Properties, we help homeowners navigate every step of the sale with expert advice, full transparency, and no pressure. Have questions about your situation? Let’s talk. Your home, your timeline, your terms—with the guidance you deserve.
By Eddie Van Buskirk January 10, 2025
Why Use Professional Services? Any financially savvy person might wonder why they should pay for a service when they could handle things themselves. It's true that you can look up contractors or take care of trash removal and cleaning on your own. However, the benefits of using a professional service often outweigh the costs. Let’s see if that scenario is true for you. The Right Tools for the Job Having the right tools can make any job significantly easier and faster. Imagine trying to chop down a tree with a hammer—it could take weeks. Using an axe might reduce the time to 30 minutes, and a well-sharpened axe could cut that down to just 15 minutes. Tackling an inherited property without the proper tools and expertise is like using a hammer on that tree. Plus, without experience, you risk unexpected problems, much like a tree falling in an unpredictable direction. Does that extra pain and struggle seem worth it for you right now? The Challenge of DIY An inherited property often arrives at an inconvenient time, adding to your already full plate. Managing it alone can quickly consume all your free time and energy, leading to stress and frustration. Benefits of Using Kansas City Legacy Properties Kansas City Legacy Properties offers a network of trusted vendors and contractors who work efficiently and effectively. We understand the best order for tasks and know how to save you money along the way. Most importantly, we handle everything while you focus on your other responsibilities. Financial Implications Holding onto a house without taking action can become a financial burden. Attempting to manage it yourself may seem cost-effective initially, but the prolonged process often results in higher holding costs. This frustration can lead to burnout and the temptation to accept a lowball offer from cash buyer companies looking to take advantage of your situation. Call to Action If you’re feeling overwhelmed and realize that handling it yourself isn’t feasible, contact us at (816) 307-7163 . Let us help turn your inherited property into a blessing rather than a burden.
By Eddie Van Buskirk October 8, 2024
This is a subtitle for your new post
By Eddie Van Buskirk September 19, 2024
I don't want to be a Landlord!
By Eddie Van Buskirk September 6, 2024
Inheriting a property isn't just about acquiring a house; it's about navigating a complex journey filled with sentimental attachments and practical challenges. It’s a realm where memories intertwine with legalities, where the weight of decisions can feel as heavy as the keys to the front door.
By Eddie Van Buskirk August 12, 2024
If you've recently inherited a property, chances are it still boasts some retro charm, like faux-wood paneling or maybe even an eye-catching orange carpet. You might be tempted to dive into a full-scale renovation, but hold onto your toolbox—there's a smarter approach. Let's face it: splurging on a major remodel might not give you the bang for your buck. Plus, new owners often prefer to put their personal touch on things. But fear not, there are a few updates that can sprinkle some magic dust on your property to help it dazzle potential buyers.
By Eddie Van Buskirk July 30, 2024
When your parents age gracefully in their own home, a quiet thought lingers: “When will they need to move?” It’s a question we all hope to avoid, but life has a way of making its own plans. The transition to a nursing home or retirement community often happens when we least expect it, placing the burden on you, the Power of Attorney, to make swift, critical decisions. Even if your loved one has a plan in place, the workload remains heavy. Let’s walk through the steps to ease this journey.
By Eddie Van Buskirk June 25, 2024
Why Your House is Not "Ugly"
By Eddie Van Buskirk June 19, 2024
What do I do with ALL the stuff? A step-by-step guide on what to do with the stuff